Recently Driven

Training

Upcoming Editorial Focus

This Month:   Industry Review & Preview / AAIW & NACE Perspectives

 

February:    Automotive Tools & Equipment / Hot Rod & Restoration

Subscriptions
Online Newsletter
Search Articles
Search Auto-Tech Schools
More Articles...
Associations
 

Malibu Hybrid offers subtle savings with steady performance
RSS Feed

The 2008 Malibu Hybrid offers styling and performance that makes it hard to separate from its conventional brethren.  In fact, the car shares the 2.4-liter Ecotec VVT four-cylinder engine and Hydra-Matic 4T45 four-speed transmission with the LS and LT version for the midsize four-door sedan.


The difference comes with the powertrain's mating to the 36-volt electric motor/generator, which forms the brawn of the GM Hybrid System.


The system allows the engine to shut off while stopped to minimize idling.  The engine automatically restarts when the driver lets off the brake pedal.  While the process involves no participation from the driver, it is sometimes disconcerting to feel the motor shutting down as you stop at a light.  I'm sure it is something that you get used to, but it does give the sensation that the car is stalling at times.


The system also allows early fuel shut-off during deceleration and captures kinetic energy through a regenerative braking system that charges the nickel metal hydride battery.  The electric motor provides additional power during launch, when needed, or at wide-open throttle, such as when passing.


The GM Hybrid system is designed to automatically maintain full accessory functionality when the vehicle is stopped, including climate control.  The A/C system allows a choice of two settings, though.  The first favors a more fuel-efficient performance by limiting the draw on the hybrid powertrain, while the normal mode provides maximum passenger comfort in hot climates and enhances defogging performance.

Although the 2008 Malibu Hybrid improves fuel economy by just two miles per gallon, you should still recoup the extra $4,000 price in fewer than 30,000 miles.
The cumulative affect of all of this technology is to improve fuel economy by two miles per gallon, boosting the 22 city/30 highway ratings to 24 city/32 highway.  The cost in performance is not really noticeable because of the assistance provided by the electric motor.  Top horsepower drops from 169 to 164, while top torque drops just one pound-foot from 160 to 159.


While the cost in performance would be hard to notice, the purchase price of $24,545 MSRP is almost $4,000 higher than the $20,550 of the base model Malibu LS.


With gas hovering at $4 a gallon and looking to be headed higher, this may begin to look like a bargain when you do the math.  That $4,000 would buy you 1,000 gallons of gas, which will carry you between 22,000 to 30,000 miles, suggesting that you will have made up the extra expense of buying the hybrid option fairly early in the car's lifecycle. 

 

 





Reader Feedback
DO THE MATH CORRECTLY! This is what\'s wrong with the whole concept of these \"simple\" hybrids. The hybrid that gets 2mpg better than the normal car will only save about 25 gallons of gas over an average 12,000 mile year of driving. That\'s $100. So to save that $4000 cost difference you\'d need to drive the car for 40 years, or 480,000 miles!
Are you guys shilling for GM or what? How could you possibly publish this without running the numbers yourselves? Your summary logic is flawed and, as a result, the article is extremely misleading. Using the EPA combined fuel consumption numbers, a fuel cost of $4.00 a gallon, and a distance traveled of 12,000 a year a 2mpg improvement will yield a fuel saving of $142.24 per year. That means the payback for the $4,000 premium for the hybrid will be just a little over 28 years. In other words, it\'s not worth the extra expense.
My eloquent if aggresive critics are correct that I mixed metaphors at the end of the article. I meant to point out that if you skipped the hybrid you could buy around 1,000 gallons of gas--enough to carry you for the first 22,000 to 30,000 miles. They are correct that the savings from the fuel efficiency would likely take more miles than you will get out of it. Scratch the last paragraph and it\'s still a nice car that may allow you to leave a barrel or two of oil on a dock somehwere half way around the world

Related Articles...
Clinton Township, Mich.--The Whistler from Katech Inc. is an electronic device that instantly determ...
Southfield, Mich.--BASF Automotive Refinish Solutions has launched a nationwide lean training progra...
Legislative issues, high-level meetings with insurers, and membership benefits were among the topics...


Parts & People is published monthly by Automotive Counseling and Publishing Company, Inc.
Copyright © 2007 Parts and People
Copyright | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy